The article criticizes journalist Arfa Khanum Sherwani, accusing her of intellectual dishonesty and selective outrage. It alleges that Sherwani and the Indian left-liberal ecosystem manipulate narratives to sanitize perceived Islamist criminality, applying moral standards based on perpetrator identity and political utility. The piece highlights a debate where Sherwani allegedly framed isolated vandalism against Christmas decorations as evidence of Christians being under attack in India, contrasting this with her alleged silence on other issues.