Despite being India's leading wicket-taker in the 2023 ODI World Cup with 24 wickets in seven matches, fast bowler Mohammed Shami has not played for India since March 2025 due to fitness concerns. The article argues that Shami's prolonged absence is difficult to rationalize, drawing parallels to the phasing out of experienced players like Pujara and Rahane. It suggests a reluctance to rely on experience rather than a decline in performance, highlighting Shami's continued effectiveness in high-stakes tournaments.